Of all the books read on air in the Mystery Babylon series, The Two Babylons is the one Cooper recommends most directly to the audience. In MB35: Christianity to Babylon he breaks into the reading to say that Alexander Hislop wrote the results of his research in a book called The Two Babylons and that he strongly suggests listeners make every attempt to get that book and read it, because it will open your eyes if you have an understanding of the symbology of the esoteric religion. The book is also cited in MB16: Sun Worship on serpent worship. Because it is long out of copyright, any listener can take that advice at no cost, and this page is written to make that reading more useful.
This page documents the historical record. It is background for listeners of the Mystery Babylon series, not an endorsement of the series’ interpretation of it. Where the broadcasts and mainstream scholarship diverge, that divergence is stated plainly. For the series itself, start with the complete episode guide.
Who Hislop Was
Alexander Hislop (1807-1865) was a Free Church of Scotland minister, based latterly at East Free Church in Arbroath. The Two Babylons began as a pamphlet in 1853 and was expanded into the book form still in print, with the fuller posthumous edition appearing in 1858 and later expanded editions after his death.
His purpose was polemical and he did not conceal it. The book’s argument is that the Roman Catholic Church is not a Christian institution at all but the ancient Babylonian mystery religion continued under Christian names, and its subtitle in most editions states that thesis outright. It belongs to a specific moment in nineteenth-century British Protestant controversy and should be read with that context in view.
What the Book Argues
The core of Hislop’s system is a triad. He argues that Babylonian religion developed around Nimrod, his wife Semiramis, and her child Tammuz, and that this mother-and-child pair is the original of every later divine mother and child in the ancient world: Isis and Horus in Egypt, Ashtoreth and Tammuz in the Levant, Venus and Cupid in Rome, and finally the Madonna and Child in Catholicism. The reading in MB35 follows precisely this line, stating that Hislop wrote in detail of how Babylonian religion developed around traditions concerning Nimrod, his wife Semiramis, and her child Tammuz.
From that root he derives a very large number of further identifications: that the Catholic mass, the mitre, the tonsure, Lent, the cross itself and much else descend from Babylonian originals. The book’s method is to find a resemblance in name, image or calendar date and treat it as evidence of descent.
The MB16 use is narrower and different in kind. There the book is cited on serpent worship, with Hislop explaining that serpent worship was not recent but an ancient practice, appearing alongside the sun as the great fire-god. That passage is being used as one comparative datum among several rather than as a whole system, which is a more defensible way to use the book.
Where the Series and Scholarship Diverge
This is the point on which a listener needs the clearest information, because the divergence here is unusually wide and unusually well documented.
Modern scholarship does not accept the central chain. The specific problem is Semiramis. Hislop’s Semiramis is built from the Greek legend of Semiramis, which is itself a much-embroidered reflection of the historical Assyrian queen Shammuramat, regent in the late ninth century BC. Nimrod appears in Genesis and is not dated or placed in any way that connects him to her. No ancient source makes them husband and wife. The marriage that carries Hislop’s entire argument is not attested anywhere; he inferred it. Assyriology as a discipline barely existed when he wrote, and the cuneiform record recovered since does not support the reconstruction.
The wider method has the same weakness at every joint. Resemblance is treated as descent without any intermediate evidence of transmission, and the etymological links are frequently unsound by the standards of comparative linguistics as it developed after his death. This has been the settled scholarly assessment for a long time, and it is shared by writers with no interest in defending Catholicism.
None of that makes the book worthless to a listener of this series. It makes it a primary source of a different kind: it is the origin of a great deal of the vocabulary and imagery the series inherits, and reading it shows exactly where certain claims entered the tradition.
How to Read It Usefully
Three habits make The Two Babylons productive rather than misleading. First, separate the observations from the inferences, because Hislop’s descriptions of ancient iconography are often accurate even where his conclusions about descent are not. Second, check every claimed etymology against a modern reference, since this is where the book fails most often and most checkably. Third, when the book asserts a relationship between two figures, ask which ancient text says so; if the answer is none, the link is Hislop’s own.
For the triad itself, see Nimrod, Semiramis and Tammuz. For the Egyptian material the book compares to, see Osiris and Isis. For the full bibliography of works read on air, see the sources page.
Every book recommended across this series is collected, with a note on what each one is actually good for, on the Top Picks reading list.


